The Cognitive Effect of AI on Humans — Curiosity over Complacency

Saygin Celen
1 day ago
6 min read

Is artificial intelligence making us smarter—or lazier?

The past few years have placed AI directly into our hands, not as abstract research but as practical tools.

Chatbots draft our emails, copilots help us code, and generative models compose everything from poems to pitch decks.

With each new release, AI slips further into everyday decision-making.

The Striking MIT Study

But emerging research suggests there may be a cognitive price. A recent MIT Media Lab study tracked 54 participants over four months as they wrote essays using either ChatGPT, a search engine, or no tool at all.

Brain activity, measured through EEG, revealed clear differences: those who wrote unaided showed the strongest neural engagement, search users fell in the middle, and ChatGPT users showed the weakest.

Even more telling, when participants who relied on AI switched back to writing without it, their brains still displayed reduced activity—especially in alpha and beta connectivity linked to memory and focus.

The numbers add weight to the concern.

Eighty-three percent of participants in the AI-supported group failed to recall key points from their own essays, compared to significantly better recall in the other groups.

Researchers call this “cognitive debt”—the cost of outsourcing too much mental effort to machines.

And yet, framing AI only as a cognitive drain misses the larger opportunity. Think of AI as a brain gym: it can weaken your mental muscles if you never exercise, or it can help you grow stronger if you train with it.

Imagine having a PhD-level companion available 24/7—ready to challenge, explain, debate, and create with you.

In the end, AI is not inherently smarter than us. It mirrors our approach. AI is as smart as we are—or as smart as who we want to be.

This paradox—cognitive offloading versus stimulating curiosity, discovery, and creativity—defines the challenge of our age.

The Cognitive Effect of AI: A Double-Edged Sword

Every major technology has altered how humans think. Calculators freed us from rote arithmetic but raised concerns about declining numeracy.

GPS eliminated the stress of navigation but also reduced our spatial memory. Psychologists call this cognitive offloading—the act of outsourcing mental effort to external tools.

AI is the next leap in offloading.

The positive edge:

AI accelerates knowledge access, augments creativity, and supports problem-solving at scale. Professionals who once needed days to research now get a curated briefing in seconds.

Students can practice with personalized tutors. Entrepreneurs can test market hypotheses overnight.

The negative edge:

Over-dependence risks mental atrophy. If we let AI write every report, summarize every book, or even generate every idea, our problem-solving abilities shrink.

Passive consumption turns active thinkers into passive recipients.

Like any tool, AI amplifies intent. The sharpness of the edge depends on how we hold it.

LIGE AI Smart Glasses: Step Into the Future

Smart Style Meets AI Power

Meet the LIGE AI Smart Glasses — where fashion-forward design meets cutting-edge technology.

Record 12 MP videos, hear HD sound music, make hand-free calls, and chat with GPT seamlessly without ever reaching your phone.

👉 Tap to unlock a new level of wearable tech — only on Awaynear

AI as a Curiosity Engine

Curiosity has always been humanity’s cognitive fuel. The printing press, radio, and internet all widened the horizon of “what if?” AI now expands it exponentially.

Prompting a model is not unlike engaging in Socratic questioning.

Instead of accepting a single answer, users can keep pressing:

“What if we invert the assumption?”

“How would a historian view this?”

“What are three alternative explanations?”

Real-world examples illustrate this well:

A high school student uses AI to simulate debates between famous philosophers to better grasp ethics.

A climate activist asks AI to role-play as future generations, reframing environmental challenges.

A novelist pushes AI to imagine “what if” scenarios that break clichés and introduce surprising narrative arcs.

AI doesn’t just answer—it provokes. But only when framed as a collaborator, not a vending machine.

AI as a Discovery Companion

Discovery once depended on access—libraries, labs, or mentors. AI collapses barriers, democratizing exploration.

Consider:

Students in remote regions use AI tutors to dive into niche fields like quantum biology or ancient linguistics, previously accessible only at elite universities.

Entrepreneurs query AI for overlooked market opportunities, discovering unmet needs by scanning patent databases or consumer forums.

Scientists employ AI for hypothesis generation, quickly testing directions before committing lab time.

These cases show that AI is not just about answers—it’s about accelerating the path to answers.

The psychological effect is powerful: guided discovery creates a cognitive “reward loop.” Each insight motivates the next question, sustaining intellectual momentum.

Rather than reducing curiosity, AI—when used well—fuels it.

AI as a Creation Catalyst

The internet was once seen as a giant library; then it became a stage. AI adds a new role: collaborator.

Treating AI as a mere content factory risks mediocrity. But using it as a co-creator transforms the process. Creators can:

Iterate through dozens of drafts in hours.

Explore multiple perspectives simultaneously.

Rapidly prototype music, design, or text without losing human voice.

A filmmaker, for instance, can use AI to storyboard ten alternate endings. A designer can test brand identities across cultures. A teacher can co-create interactive learning journeys for students.

The winning formula is not AI alone or human alone. It is human originality + AI scalability.

The Risk:

Laziness and Cognitive Atrophy

But here lies the danger. If AI becomes the default substitute for thinking, we risk losing the very skills it augments.

The analogy is clear in social media: infinite scrolling delivers dopamine but rarely insight.

Passive AI use—“give me the answer, write my essay, solve my problem”—creates similar mental inertia.

Cognitive laziness is the hidden tax of convenience.

The risk is subtle because the outputs often look intelligent. But beneath polished text or sleek slides may lie shallow reasoning.

Over time, our own intellectual muscles weaken.

Technology history shows the pattern: tools that save effort must be balanced with practices that preserve skill.

Practical Framework:

Using AI Without Losing Your Edge

How can individuals harness AI without succumbing to complacency? One approach is the 3C framework:

Curiosity:

Never accept outputs at face value. Keep asking questions, exploring variations, and pushing deeper.

Challenge:

Test AI’s answers against reality, data, and your own judgment. Fact-check relentlessly.

Creation:

Use AI to extend your work—draft faster, explore alternatives—but let your originality guide direction.

Practical applications:

Professionals can use AI for ideation but finalize strategy themselves.

Students should treat AI as a tutor that explains concepts differently, not as a homework machine.

Entrepreneurs might use AI for early research but validate with real customers.

Adopting these practices keeps humans in the driver’s seat.

Lessons for the Future of Human-AI Symbiosis

The future is not about humans vs. AI—it is about symbiosis.

Think of AI as an intellectual gym. Just as weights can either build muscle or gather dust,

AI can either sharpen thought or replace it. The responsibility lies in the user’s habits.

Education systems must adapt. It’s no longer enough to teach “how to use AI.”

We must teach how to think with AI. This means cultivating:

Critical thinking to question outputs.

Originality to inject human creativity.

Values to guide ethical use.

And here’s the truth: AI reflects us. It mirrors the way we prompt it, push it, and partner with it. It is as smart as we are—or as smart as who we want to be.

AI doesn’t have to make us lazy.

It can be the greatest tool for curiosity, discovery, and creativity of our era.

The choice is ours.

So as we close this Innovation Party edition, here’s the real invitation: Reflect on your relationship with AI.

How are you using AI daily?

The next chapter of human intelligence may not be written by AI, but by how we decide to engage with it.

Awaynear — Where Ideas Scale

Design, tech, AI & ventures — we help startups and creators launch and grow.

Digital: Landing pages, decks & no-code builds
Ventures: Coffee, balloons, AI tools & more
Shop: Top-rated gadgets & lifestyle gear
AI Tools: OKRs, prompts & productivity hacks

🔗 Discover Awaynear how a team of experts can launch and grow your company wherever you are in the world and how we can add personalized high value to your lifestyle.